Three marketers who are all working in non-traditional ways with agencies spoke at last night’s (2 September) OysterCatchers’ event called Shaping the New Brand/Agency Model.
Head of marketing for British Airways Abi Comber, who recently reviewed and consolidated her agency roster, said that her new set up delivered far more integrated ideas and creative execution.
She added: “We were not getting integrated thinking and I wouldn’t [expect to] get it if I briefed multiple agencies. We used to spend a lot of our time bringing everybody together rather than on the actual issues. … now it’s far more about ideas, not advertising.”
“For me the idea has to be at the heart of everything and we spend more of our time talking about ideas rather than managing the process and bitching about each other’s diaries.”
Philip Gladman, who recently vacated the role of marketing and innovation director Africa at Diageo, said, stressing it was his own view, that Diageo had too many agencies and there were often five agencies working on one brand.
However, he added that the drinks company did have many different brands, ranging from premium to mass market, which required different creative approaches unlikely to be provided by one agency.
Gladman said that this approach really need a strong, creative minded marketing director to keep several agencies on the same track and added: “The percentage of time we get to spend on creative directing is getting less all the time because marketers are dragged into so many different facets of the business. There is a direct correlation between the time a senior marketer gets to work on a business and the creative output.”
Gladman, who is now leading a marketing team parachuted into Hovis on a short term contract, added: “I have always believed in the meritocracy of agencies and have always tried to find who is the hottest and newest – I have followed teams from big agencies who have formed start-ups.”
Ian Armstrong, global marketing communications director for Jaguar, which has a joint venture set-up with agency Spark 44, added that the big challenge was to dig out the compelling stories that existed around the brand and develop them with the agency.
He said while Spark 44 was set up to service Jaguar it has a remit to find other client business and he welcomed the ‘kick up the pants’ other marketing directors could give the agency.