BMP scales the sunlit uplands

Consistency is a rare virtue in advertising agency circles – but J Walter Thompson has had it in spades. For most of the last decade it has managed to dominate the annual Marketing Week ad agency league table – which monitors reputations where they really matter: among senior clients.

Not this year, though. It has lost pride of place to BMP DDB, which has scaled the pinnacle for the first time in the 11 years we have been running the survey. This was no fluke, however. BMP won comfortably on four of the nine criteria which make up the league and was outright winner in the two closest to clients’ hearts: creativity and value for money.

Whether this marks the beginning of a long BMP ascendancy remains to be seen. But the omens, for what they are worth, are good. Surveys of this kind, by their nature, are more reliable tracking long-term trends than highlighting immediate incident. BMP has acquired a steady upward momentum, from number seven two years ago, to number two and now to pole position. The momentum is mirrored in the creative and value for money tables; and inversely by JWT’s marked deterioration in the creative department (although it continues to perform well in providing value for money).

That said, we should not discount the impact of all recent external events on the views of interviewees. Marketing directors may be famously dismissive of the amount of time they spend on advertising matters, but that’s not to say they don’t read their trade press with interest. There, they will have encountered a year packed with incident for the advertising world, featuring unprecedented revenue growth, unprecedented consolidation and some astonishing account and people moves.

It seems unlikely, for example, that their judgement will have been wholly uninfluenced by the news, broken in this magazine, that JWT’s chief executive was about to jump overboard to NTL in far from amicable circumstances (the survey was conducted soon afterwards, in October). Equally, they will have picked up on the negative headlines fanfaring WCRS’ disastrous performance this year. And perhaps Publicis’ high-profile takeover activity may have had something to do with its vastly improved performance in the league table (it has made it into the top ten).

In the end, it hardly matters. Whether you take the long or short-term view, whether you believe the client’s view enlightened or ignorant, what’s important is perception. Here, ad agencies could do more to help themselves. They are notoriously bad at promoting their own reputations. And yet, as the pressures grow on clients’ time and the competition to ad agencies’ skills multiplies, it is surely incumbent upon them to address this problem – or fall further down the value chain.

Recommended

Carat plans centralised media negotiating arm

Marketing Week

Carat Group UK is centralising trading negotiations with major media owners across its three media companies, Carat, BBJ Media and Feather Brooksbank. All three businesses will remain as separate operating companies and the change will not affect their independent strategic media planning and buying operations. The move follows recent consolidations and changes in media ownership, […]

TiVo homework for the outdoors

Marketing Week

I am pleased that Graham Appleby is a great deal better informed then I am about the potential for personal video recorders such as the TiVo system to decimate TV audiences. I bow to his expert view! (MW November 16). As for Graham’s clarion call to TV executives everywhere to boycott poster advertising by closing […]

AXA takes on ex-Pru chief Frank Wilson

Marketing Week

AXA Sun Life, the life insurance brand of the insurance and asset management company AXA, has appointed the former marketing director at Prudential Retail, Frank Wilson, as its new marketing director. Wilson will control all marketing activity and takes over the role of marketing strategy director from Rob Lee, who has been given the title […]

Comments

    Leave a comment