‘Cliche’ car ads charge is unfair

Lucy Barrett’s article on pan-European car advertising “Gearing down” (MW April 6) is muddled, poorly edited, and an oversimplification of the facts.

She describes the UK car campaigns of the past 20 years as “lavish and wasteful”, but then goes on to praise local creativity.

The so-called 15 per cent contribution that advertising makes towards the cost of a UK car an erroneous calculation based on total marketing and media costs. The cost of local productions are a tiny fraction of the £750m media spend, and so pan-European advertising provides a negligible saving to the total cost.

Finally, not all pan-European ads have to ” resort to cliches”. In the opinion of British consumers the latest (pan-European) Fiat Brava commercial is funny, memorable and above all else, a relevant observation on what real family life is like. Some insights do travel, and not a desert or lake in sight.

Daniel Taylor

Board Account Director

D’Arcy, London


The real aim of Net campaigns

Marketing Week

I read with interest Jeremy Paul’s media comment on dot-com advertising, “Websites must act like brands to be successful” (MW last week). He makes the point that most dot-com advertising is only geared to building awareness and not the brand. But I feel Jeremy has rather missed the point. Call me an old cynic, if […]

Will new banks travel well too?

Marketing Week

While I welcome Tom Bawden’s article about the challenges of creating a pan-European banking brand (“Internet opens up Europe for banks” MW April 20), it failed to examine the role new banks such as Tesco Personal Finance and EasyGroup’s Easymoney will play in this trend. With the exception of Easymoney, the article suggests the majority […]

Go for green and forget motives

Marketing Week

So there is “immense ecology fatigue” in Middle England, your leader column states last week. The power companies may indeed be far from altruistic in launching their green energy schemes in an attempt to position themselves as eco-friendly, but this does not alter the fact that we must all embrace sustainable energy sources or face […]


    Leave a comment