Facebook admits 9% of users are fakes

Facebook has revealed that about 9 per cent of its 955 million “active” users are likely to be fake profiles, meaning marketers could be paying to advertise to “people” who do not exist.


The social network’s filings to the US Securities and Exchange Commission revealed that more than 83 million profiles (8.7 per cent of its monthly active user base) are actually false and in violation of its terms of service.

Facebook said that “duplicate” accounts, which a user maintains in addition to his or her principal account, may have represented up to 4.8 per cent of its monthly active users.

It also revealed that about 2.4 per cent of its active users are actually mis-classified accounts, which people have created for a business, organisation or a pet rather than using a page.

Approximately 1.5 per cent of its monthly active users were found to be “undesirable” accounts that are deliberately intended to be used to violate its terms of service for uses such as spamming.

Facebook says the percentage of fake accounts are “meaningfully lower” in developed markets such as the US and Australia, compared with developing markets such as Indonesia and Turkey.

The company adds: “We are continually seeking to improve our ability to identify duplicate or false accounts and estimate the total number of such accounts, and such estimates may be affected by improvements or changes in our methodology.”

The revelations could have a major impact on Facebook, which relies on advertisers for the bulk of its revenue. Brands could now be more wary about paying to place ads on Facebook if the social network cannot prove their spots are actually reaching a real targeted audience.

The news comes a week after digital distribution company Limited Run carried out analysis on its Facebook advertising and found that 80 per cent of the clicks on its ads had come from “bots”, through its own analysis.

Limited Run’s post about its analysis went viral and the company has now decided to delete its Facebook page. Facebook says it is in contact with Limited Run and will look into the issues it has had.

The debate into the value of Facebook to marketers has heated up in recent months. Doubts have been cast over the effectiveness of its ad formats such as Reach Generator, which “guarantees” page posts will be seen by at least 75% of a brand’s fans – the revelations about false accounts are likely to heighten concern.

Facebook has attempted to defend itself against critics with a series of case studies.

Andy Pang, Facebook’s EMEA head of customer market insights, also recently told marketers not to get “too hung up on CTR”.


Ruth Mortimer

IOC’s brand blockade is starting to break

Ruth Mortimer

The London 2012 Olympics will go down in history as the first Games where even the ambush marketers got ambushed. Australian insurance firm iSelect is currently running an ad that plays on the notoriety of those brands unofficially cashing in on the Olympics… while conveniently promoting itself. Apart from the iSelect cash-in, ambush marketing at […]

Seb Joseph

Pressure on Chevrolet to fulfil global dreams

Seb Joseph

General Motors’ tie-ups with Manchester Utd and Liverpool give Chevrolet the global staging platform to extend the brand beyond North America, providing it has faith in the sponsorship strategies laid out by its recently departed CMO Joel Ewanick.