Ikea: Criticism of campaigns that champion diversity only pushes us on

John Lewis, Maltesers and Tesco have all faced criticism for their decision to create more diverse advertising. However, marketers have a responsibility to ensure they are representing society, according to Ikea’s marketing boss.

Ikea has been running its ‘The Wonderful Everyday’ campaign for the past four years and credits it with bringing more personality and understanding of what the brand stands for to the UK market. And it says a big reason it has been successful is its focus on diversity.

The company’s most recent TV spot, ‘Hooray! To the Wonderful Everyday’ features a family celebrating life’s small victories and simple pleasures. Created by agency Mother, it has been widely praised for featuring a black family and for making a positive contribution to the discourse on race. But not everybody was happy about the ad. Some have called it racist for not featuring any white people (and that’s just the criticism that we’re able to publish).

Ikea is not the only brand to make a clear decision to be more diverse and inclusive in its advertising. Both the John Lewis and Marks & Spencer’s Christmas ads feature mixed race parents, while Tesco’s shows a Muslim family celebrating Christmas.

Yet while reaction has been mostly positive, there has been criticism for all these campaigns. Some have even called for a boycott of Tesco, although the supermarket giant is ignoring such criticism, saying: “Everyone is welcome at Tesco this Christmas and we’re proud to celebrate the many ways our customers come together over the festive season.”

John Lewis, Marks & Spencer, Tesco have all made the decision to create a real, lovely, diverse wave of communication that has also received criticism. But all that should do is drive us forward more and more.

Kemi Anthony, Ikea

For Ikea’s Kemi Anthony, the criticism was expected but she says it just motivates the brand to do even more diverse campaigns.

“The Wonderful Everyday was never just an endline and [it is] important that The Wonderful Everyday really speaks to who we are as a brand and that includes how we treat people and how we celebrate and want to include everyone,” she said, speaking today (14 November) at Creativebrief’s Bite Live event in London. “With the launch of our most recent campaign we’ve had lots and lots of lovely commentary but we’ve also had a few not so nice comments.

“John Lewis, Marks & Spencer, Tesco have all made the decision to create a real, lovely, diverse wave of communication that has also received criticism. But all that should do is drive us forward more and more.

She added: “We all have a big responsibility and we need to work harder to make sure we are representing the people who live in the world around us. If we are not working hard enough hopefully you’ll go away thinking you can try harder with what we’re doing and how we’re representing different groups in society.”

READ MORE: Ikea – We work as closely with our agencies as we do our furniture designers

Maltesers is another example of a brand at the vanguard of creating a more diverse advertising landscape. Having won Channel 4’s first Diversity in Advertising award, the retailer, along with its agency AMV BBDO, created a series of ads featuring disabled people.

Reaction was mostly positive, from consumers, the business and even the government. Maltesers was hoping sales would rise 4% due to the campaign, but they were up an even higher 8% while brand affinity measures also increased and the company was invited to talk to parliament about the positive role diverse advertising can play in societal change.

However, Mars’ marketing VP Michele Oliver admitted the brand did get a “load of shit from a vocal minority”. In fact, the ad was also one of the most complained about last year, according to the Advertising Standards Authority.

I hope [diversity] becomes a commodity. At this point [it’s] great that maybe there is brand advantage. But I hope being first means there is a second, third, fourth, fifth and it just becomes stories of people.

Michele Oliver, Maltesers

Oliver hopes this doesn’t put other brands off improving diversity and inclusion and said the aim should be for one day diversity to be a commodity, not a brand advantage.

“To make the Maltesers ads we had to go to a specialist casting agency to recruit disabled women. Therefore, by definition, any ad that we make if you don’t explicitly say ‘we would consider having a disabled person’ you will never get a disabled person in your ad,” she added. “You should have a casting agency and a character and the list of people you look at has the most appropriate and therefore the most diverse representation of society.”

“I hope [diversity] becomes a commodity. At this point [it’s] great that maybe there is brand advantage because we’re able to tell some stories that haven’t been told because unfortunately the stories of people with disabilities, or older women or women of colour or lesbian women or single mothers haven’t been told and maybe we can be the first to tell them. But I hope being first means there is a second, third, fourth, fifth and it just becomes stories of people.”

Recommended

Knowledge Bank

Comments

There is one comment at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. Julian Pratt 15 Nov 2017

    “Criticism” is the new currency.

    There are 65 million opinions in the UK at any time, so scanning down the daily mail comments is a easy/lazy way to make a “story” out of nothing and cash in.

    The danger comes when reality and commercial trolling blur and the “low hanging fruit” is actually a diversion or poisoned.

    Who is criticising? An industry watchdog, the serial complainer in the local paper, or something more sinister,

    https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/nov/14/how-400-russia-run-fake-accounts-posted-bogus-brexit-tweets

    If we don’t learn to look in the gift horses mouth we can end up damaging the channels that we need to make our living on.

Leave a comment

Subscribers enjoy unlimited access to unrivalled coverage of the biggest issues in marketing, alongside practical advice from the digital experts at Econsultancy.

With a subscription to Marketing Week Premium you will get full access to:

> World-renowned columnists

> Analysis & case studies

> Exclusive leading-edge insight

> Carefully curated reports & briefings from Econsultancy

> Plus, much more including a £300 discount for the Festival of Marketing

Subscribe now