Moody elite need to get a creative grip

I applaud Iain Murray’s advice to the industry’s creative leaders to keep their mouths shut in the wider world for fear of muddling everyone else (“Confused world of creativity,” MW July 15). But his analysis of their state of mind is flawed.

There are two basic reasons for the self-absorbed neurosis of the creative elite.

First, the fact that these industry Maharishis can spend five days at a “creative summit” in Sunderland in September disappearing up their own fundamentals, suggests they spend little time actually creating and most of their time just talking about it.

I suspect that many of these leaders – lionised for their past achievements – have now promoted themselves to executive creative roles and are out of touch with the creative departments they serve.

No wonder they see the creative world as unreliable, elitist and incapable of free thinking. After all, the higher you climb up the greasy pole, the more you feel your own bottom is exposed to view.

Secondly, in this smoke and mirrors business, the word “creative” has been badly misappropriated. And that can all too easily lead to a state of terminal insecurity among its principal exponents.

The very suggestion that you can put a promotional scratchcard in the same league as The Venus de Milo has always been laughable. Art directors, copywriters and hands-on creative directors don’t have any trouble with that thought or believe that it stifles originality. For them, it does not trigger an existential nightmare.

The only people who get insecure are the creative elite – whose sole task it is to stand up and make grandiose claims about industry “creativity” while knowing that to succeed, it has to plunder popular culture, not lead it.

What accounts for the moody self-analysis among the creative industry’s great and good is that the truth hurts. Which leads me to this simple piece of psychotherapeutic advice: c’mon guys, get a grip.

Dan Douglas

Creative director

DP&A

London W1

Recommended

Exchange rates lead to block

Marketing Week

George Pitcher ascribes the fact that car prices in the UK are higher than in Europe to block exemption (MW July 15). This is not true, as block exemption exists throughout Europe. The difference is carried by exchange rates – experts reckon that the real exchange rate is about 75p to the euro, not 65p. […]

Kellogg plots Euro launch for functional food range

Marketing Week

Kellogg is planning to launch its functional food brand Ensemble in Europe. The 20-strong range, only available in Michigan in the US, claims to reduce the risk of coronary heart disease by lowering cholesterol. A Kellogg spokeswoman confirms the company intends to bring Ensemble to Europe: “There are plans to go international. In fact, we […]

Cruel fate of the loveable pashmina

Marketing Week

Try as I may, I am seldom able to help the Daily Mail in its restless search for the answers to questions such as “Why are men so bad at growing old?”, “How do you rate in the great two Jags class quiz?”, “So who says it’s fun to be 50?”, and “Could Julie Birchall […]

Comments

    Leave a comment