P&G drops ‘unfair’ Fairy Traditional ads

Procter & Gamble has been forced to ditch its TV campaign for recently launched dishwasher detergent, Fairy Traditional, because its claims about rival brands were misleading and unfair.

Procter & Gamble has been forced to ditch its TV campaign for recently launched dishwasher detergent, Fairy Traditional, because its claims about rival brands were misleading and unfair.

The Broadcast Advertising Clearance Centre (BACC) ordered P&G to take the ads off the air, following complaints from German-owned household goods rival, Benckiser.

Benckiser, which owns rival dishwasher detergent brand Finish, says the ad claimed most tra- ditional detergents could scratch glasses. It also claimed the commercial showed a glass which was clouded, not scratched.

Benckiser marketing director Keith Edwards says: “We had a fundamental problem with the claim [P&G] was making.

“There is a large body of evidence that failures in manufacturing of glasses, not detergents, are responsible for glass scratching,” adds Edwards.

Edwards says the claims had not adversely affected the performance of his company’s products. Share of Benckiser’s Finish dishwashing products rose from 41 per cent to 46 per cent by value in the three months to July.

The BACC had already passed the ads, which began running in May, as the technical arguments concerning scratching were not investigated at the time.

A P&G spokeswoman said the ads would be modified.

Recommended

Orange in direct sales trial as OFT probe starts

Marketing Week

Orange, the mobile phone company, has begun trials to sell its handsets directly to customers. The move comes just days after the Office of Fair Trading announced an official investigation into alleged price-fixing through dealers. The Hutchison Telecom division is the subject of an OFT probe following complaints from a number of Orange dealers that […]

True Interbrand evaluations

Marketing Week

I entirely agree with Torsten Nilson’s view in “Microsoft story hard to swallow” (MW July 28) that brand valuations should be based on an analytical, marketing-oriented model. This has been Interbrand’s approach since 1988. Since then, we have conducted more than 1,200 brand valuations – with a combined value of 40bn – for use in […]

Falling head over wheels in love

Marketing Week

A word of advice for DMB&B chairman Graham Hinton, officially back on the job market for the first time in ten years – don’t send your CV to the offices of Banks Hoggins O’Shea. The Diary was recounted a timeless little tale regarding the agency’s colourful managing partner John Banks. Apparently, as a penniless (surely […]

Comments

    Leave a comment