Sales house throws new punch in CIA fight

ITV sales house Laser has upped the stakes in its 2m overtrading dispute with CIA Medianetwork by alleging in letters written to CIA’s clients that the media buyer was prepared to inflate clients’ airtime costs by 1m to meet its 1996 commitments to Laser.

The letter is highly embarrass-ing to CIA and comes as Laser’s solicitors prepare to issue a writ against the media buyer. The letter implies that the agency was willing to let its clients, including Daewoo and Lloyds/TSB, pick up an expected 1m shortfall in 1996.

The disputed money arises because of the practice of media agencies being given discounts based on the share of spending they are willing to guarantee to each ITV sales house.

Laser alleges that CIA failed to meet its 1995 and 1996 commitments because it spent a smaller share than was initially promised. In 1995, CIA Media-network spent 14.6m with Laser’s broadcasters. In the nine months to September this year the agency had spent 10.4m.

Some observers believe the unprecedented legal threat could force a massive change in a practice which has been criticised for a number of years.

CIA’s share price dropped 17p on Monday to 132p and closed at 133.5p yesterday (Tuesday). It is understood that the group had been planning a 15m-plus rights issue before the overtrading issue first broke in August (MW August 2). The legal spat, however, may jeopardise its success.

“The letter states the degree to which CIA asked Laser to hike their (Laser’s) rates to cover the 1996 debt,” says one source close to clients who have received the letter. “The individual letters give details of the proposals that CIA made to sort out the deal.”

Laser’s clients, Granada, York-shire Tyne Tees, LWT and Border, first consulted lawyers on the matter at the beginning of October. A Granada source says: “We have been discussing the 1996 position and CIA has chosen to instruct Laser to increase rates to the end of the year.”

CIA Group chairman Chris Ingram declined to comment on how the letter would affect his client relationships. “We are still in discussions and no writ has been served so far,” says Ingram.

CIA Medianetwork managing director Mike Tunnicliffe has written to all its clients claiming that Laser has used “some rather heavy handed and aggressive tactics,” and asks clients to refer any approaches from Laser directly to CIA. But some CIA clients admit that they are “concerned” about the allegations, which also threaten to prevent CIA buying airtime in the four ITV regions concerned, unless the dispute is resolved before January 1.

“Every client needs a seven-day London schedule and national presence on ITV, not to mention the ability to trust its agency,” says Media Audits managing director John Storey, which advises over 150 UK advertisers on their media spend.

Laser claims almost 1m is owed from CIA’s 1995 commitments: 785,081 to YTTV, 74,722 to Granada, 115,201 to LWT and 4,353 to Border. It is understood that CIA owes a similar amount on its 1996 deal.

Laser believes CIA failed to meet its guarantees because it has been encouraged to spend a higher share of its clients’ money in rival Carlton Sales’ regions in London and Central. Both Ingram and Carlton Sales managing director Martin Bowley deny any special relationship between the sales house and the agency.

TSMS, United News & Media’s sales house, has a similar trading dispute with CIA and is studying the outcome of Laser’s legal action.

Industry observers are divided on whether the agreements made between sales houses and agencies on the basis of share of ITV spend constitute legally binding contracts. “I think it’s just tactics, leaking this information to the press. It’s all dirty tricks,” says Lorna Tilbian, Panmure Gordon’s media analyst.

Even if the CIA/Laser clash is settled without going to court, the legal threat will change the way airtime is bought and sold. For many clients that could be the most positive result.

Recommended

New cable giant has a way to go

Marketing Week

Cable & Wireless’ purchase of Nynex, Bell and Videotron turned it into the UK’s market leader. But improved distribution isn’t the same as convincing people they want cable services.

Thresher Wine Shop tests Adventure Card loyalty scheme

Marketing Week

Off-licence chain Thresher Wine Shop is testing a new loyalty scheme called the Adventure Card to support its television advertising campaign, which uses the tag line: “Adventures in wine – guaranteed.” The scheme offers one point for every pound spent on wines, although customers have to spend at least 3.99. With 25 points, customers can […]

Enid stories put blight on her centenary

Marketing Week

Like any right-thinking person, the Diary is always mortified when sex and one’s own parents are talked about in the same breath. But it was doubly mortifying when Enid Blyton’s sexual conquests, and there are more than you would expect, were retraced in front of her now elderly daughter, Gillian Baverstock. Comedian Tony Robinson, a […]

Comments

    Leave a comment

    Close

    Discover even more as a subscriber

    This article is available for subscribers only.

    Sign up now for your access-all-areas pass.

    If you're an existing paid print subscriber find out how to get access here.

    Subscribers enjoy unlimited access to unrivalled coverage of the biggest issues in marketing, alongside practical advice from the digital experts at Econsultancy.

    With a subscription to Marketing Week Premium you will get full access to:

    > World-renowned columnists

    > Analysis & case studies

    > Exclusive leading-edge insight

    > Carefully curated reports & briefings from Econsultancy

    > Plus, much more including a £300 discount for the Festival of Marketing

    Subscribe now

    Got a question?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3703 or email customerservices@marketingweek.com

    If you are looking for our Jobs site, please click here

    Subscribers enjoy unlimited access to unrivalled coverage of the biggest issues in marketing, alongside practical advice from the digital experts at Econsultancy.

    With a subscription to Marketing Week Premium you will get full access to:

    > World-renowned columnists

    > Analysis & case studies

    > Exclusive leading-edge insight

    > Carefully curated reports & briefings from Econsultancy

    > Plus, much more including a £300 discount for the Festival of Marketing

    Subscribe now